In this case, it would seem that total pleasure is best promoted by killing the one healthy patient, harvesting his organs and saving the other five lives their pleasure outweighs the cost to the formerly healthy patient. Imagine a case where a doctor had five patients requiring new organs to stop their death and one healthy patient undergoing a routine check. Judith Jarvis Thomson (1929–) raised the problem of the “transplant surgeon”. However, this focus on the outcome of individual acts can sometimes lead to odd and objection-raising examples. In addition to a difference in views regarding the importance of the quality of a pleasure, Mill and Bentham are also separated by reference to Act and Rule Utilitarianism and although such terms emerged only after Mill’s death, Mill is typically considered a rule utilitarian and Bentham an act utilitarian.Īn act utilitarian, such as Bentham, focuses only on the consequences of individual actions when making moral judgments.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |